North Cape May Real Estate

There are a lot of places that are good to call home, but for a community that offers quiet living near the water, North Cape May could be the perfect destination. Nestled on the tip of the Cape May Peninsula in New Jersey, buying a home for sale in North Cape May is an idyllic option for those who want to settle down away from the hustle and bustle of real life.

Cape May is one of New Jersey's most popular tourist destinations. In the summer, Cape May sometimes welcomes up to 40,000 temporary residents, all of whom want to take advantage of the quiet coastline and small town ambiance. Cape May is regularly recognized for its pristine beaches, and it is also designated as one of the top birdwatching locations in the whole country.

Although much of the city caters to summer tourists, about 3,500 residents do call the area home all year round. Much of the year-long population is settled in North Cape May, a small enclave within the greater community. There are many hotels in the rest of the city, but North Cape May is almost entirely residential. This ensures more privacy and less congestion in the summer. With so much history, it is easy to find Victorian-style homes and other classic architectures. However, newer developments continue to be built, giving North Cape May real estate buyers options for condos, bungalows and more.

Clearly, a North Cape May home can be the perfect place to settle down. Whether you are interested in a permanent summer getaway or a year-round home, there are plenty of North Cape May real estate options to consider. We can help you navigate the market to find a home that fits your needs and your budget. See below for our homes for sale in North Cape May.

MLS Search Results

Map All Results

503 Whildam $649,900

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250476
    Status: Active
    Address: 503 Whildam
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 7,501
    Kind: Single Family
    • 2 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    "Experience effortless coastal living in this meticulously remodeled 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom gem. No detail has been... Read More

715 Eldredge $725,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250454
    Status: Active
    Address: 715 Eldredge
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 7749.32
    Kind: Single Family
    • 3 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Welcome to 715 Eldredge Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, a beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offering 1,275 sq.... Read More

58 Heron $515,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250450
    Status: Active
    Address: 58 Heron
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 73x135
    Kind: Single Family
    • 3 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch home is situated on an oversized lot, offering privacy and tranquility as the... Read More

5 Kenvil $399,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250427
    Status: Active
    Address: 5 Kenvil
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 40x100
    Zoning: res
    Kind: Single Family
    • 2 Bedrooms
    • 1 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Ranch style home just a few short blocks to the Bay and the best Sunsets you will ever see. 2 bedrooms and 1 bath with a... Read More

504 Holmes $515,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250376
    Status: Active
    Address: 504 Holmes
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 85x100
    Kind: Single Family
    • 2 Bedrooms
    • 1 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Seashore and Small Town Charm! This property offers a rare opportunity to own a home with a spacious 85x100 corner lot... Read More

3604 Bayshore $525,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250306
    Status: Active
    Address: 3604 Bayshore
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 9,374sq ft
    Kind: Single Family
    • 2 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Welcome to 3604 Bayshore Rd in North Cape May! This oversized 2-bedroom, 2-bath rancher is perfectly situated just a... Read More

12 Mimosa $524,900

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250300
    Status: Active
    Address: 12 Mimosa
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 75x164 irr
    Zoning: Res
    Kind: Single Family
    • 4 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Seller is requesting Best & Final Offers By Monday 2/17/27 at 10am. This home has so much to offer! As you enter the... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250249
    Status: Active
    Address: 3823 A Bayshore
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Zoning: Commercial
  • Description:
    Commercial Rental- One or Two units available. Unit A- Consists of a reception area, and three other rooms with a... Read More

702 Gordon $626,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250241
    Status: Active
    Address: 702 Gordon
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 58x106
    Kind: Single Family
    • 2 Bedrooms
    • 1 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Charming Fully Renovated Rancher Just Six Blocks from the Bay! Discover this beautifully updated two-bedroom,... Read More

225 Suzanne $615,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 250218
    Status: Active
    Address: 225 Suzanne
    City / Zip: North Cape May, NJ 8204
    Lot Size: 6499
    Kind: Single Family
    • 3 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Completely renovated! Fresh and better than new, this lovely revamped rancher is ready for new owners. An ideal beach... Read More