Cape May Real Estate Listings

Cape May is a beautiful seaside town with stunning sunsets. It is no surprise that so many people seek out Cape May vacation homes. Cape May is home to about 4,000 year-round residents but around 40,000 seasonal residents.

Cape May real estate has been steadily growing in value over the past few decades. In 2000, the median value of a home or condo in Cape May, NJ was almost $228,000. In 2016, the median value had more than doubled to approximately $547,000. The mean price of all housing units for sale in Cape May in 2016 was just over $822,000. 

Cape May has been a popular retirement community for many years and has long been famous for its many beautiful Victorian style homes. Cape May's collection of Victorian style homes is the second largest of any city in the United States, following closely behind San Francisco. Its reputation for having such a vast number of Victorian style homes earned the entire city a National Historic Landmark designation in 1976.

The town offers many amenities such as its spectacular assortment of both fine dining and casual restaurants, its many art and cultural festivals held throughout the year, its scenic boardwalk, and its pristine beach that is ranked as one of the Top 10 Beaches in the USA by the Travel Channel. Cape May also has a great school system and a below average crime rate.

See below for all of our Cape May homes for sale. To find homes for sale in surrounding areas, see all locations.

 

MLS Search Results

Map All Results

24 Jackson Street $4,995,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 240935
    Status: Active
    Address: 24 Jackson Street
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 51 x 112
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 8 Bedrooms
    • 8 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Unique opportunity to own this Edwardian-era Seaside Mansion on Historic Jackson Street in Cape May! The property... Read More

24 Jackson Street $4,995,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 240887
    Status: Active
    Address: 24 Jackson Street
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 51 x 112
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 8 Bedrooms
    • 8 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Unique opportunity to own this Edwardian-era Seaside Mansion on Historic Jackson Street in Cape May! The property... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 232455
    Status: Active
    Address: 202 Ocean Street #206 Ocean Street
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 7900
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 13 Bedrooms
    • 11 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Don’t miss this opportunity to own a piece of Cape May history. Currently operated as the Captain Mey's Inn, this turn... Read More

2 Pharo Lane $3,990,000

  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 233173
    Status: Active
    Address: 2 Pharo Lane
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 31x61
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 4 Bedrooms
    • 2 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Welcome to 2 Pharo, a 4-story, single family property, iconic to Cape May's Marina District and the surrounding... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 232394
    Status: Active
    Address: 805 Stockton Avenue
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 79 x 110
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 12 Bedrooms
    • 12 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    Amazing opportunity to own an extremely large and incredibly well maintained Victorian Cape May beach block home in the... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 232354
    Status: Active
    Address: 805 Stockton Avenue
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 79 x 110
  • Description:
    This is a rare opportunity to own one of Cape May's most pristine, historic bed and breakfasts! The Bedford Inn has been... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 223553
    Status: Active
    Address: 1516 New York Avenue
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 75x125
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 6 Bedrooms
    • 4 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    4,771 sq foot Magnificent 3 story, North Point Beach, Cape May home. So much to mention but home has been totally... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 241018
    Status: Active
    Address: 1047 Virginia Avenue
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 75 x 125
    Kind: Single Family Residence
    • 5 Bedrooms
    • 3 Bathrooms
  • Description:
    AMAZING RENTAL PROPERTY WITH AN IN-GROUND POOL! Over $247,000 of gross income in 2023 with $265,000 gross income on the... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 232833
    Status: Active
    Address: 1013 Stockton Avenue
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 50 x 105
    Kind: Duplex
  • Description:
    Introducing a spectacular Cape May gem nestled just one block away from the pristine Queen Street Beach, this... Read More
  • Property Highlights
    MLS #: 240688
    Status: Active
    Address: 933 Washington Street
    City / Zip: Cape May, NJ 08204
    Lot Size: 15,000+/-
    Kind: Apartment
  • Description:
    An “extremely flexible opportunity” that doesn’t come along very often! The historic Thomas Webster House, built in... Read More
Latest News from Our Blog